If you’ve ever had an authentic Philly cheesesteak, you know that the bread is just as important as the steak and cheese. A great cheesesteak isn’t just about perfectly grilled beef and melty cheese—it’s also about the roll that holds it all together. The right bread ensures that every bite is flavorful, soft, and slightly chewy, with just the right amount of structure to keep all the delicious fillings intact.
But with so many bread options available, what is the best choice for a Philly cheesesteak? In this guide, we’ll explore the best bread options, why certain rolls are more authentic, and how to prepare them for the ultimate cheesesteak experience. Whether you’re making a classic Philly cheesesteak at home or just curious about what makes it special, this article will answer all your questions.
In the next section, we’ll dive into what makes a Philly cheesesteak authentic and why bread plays a critical role in achieving the perfect sandwich.
Table of Contents
What Makes a Philly Cheesesteak Authentic?
A Philly cheesesteak isn’t just any sandwich—it’s an iconic piece of Philadelphia’s food culture. To truly understand what kind of bread works best, we need to look at the key components of a traditional cheesesteak.
The Role of Bread in a Cheesesteak
While the thinly sliced ribeye steak and gooey melted cheese (whether it’s Cheez Whiz, American, or Provolone) are essential, the bread is the foundation of the sandwich. The right roll should:
- Be soft but sturdy – It must hold the filling without falling apart.
- Have a slight chewiness – This helps create the perfect bite with the steak and cheese.
- Be lightly crisp on the outside – A slight crust prevents the roll from becoming soggy.
If the bread is too soft and airy, it won’t hold up to the juicy meat and cheese, making the sandwich fall apart. On the other hand, if the bread is too crusty, it overpowers the fillings and makes the cheesesteak harder to eat.
Now that we understand why bread is so important, let’s explore the best bread options for a Philly cheesesteak.
Best Type of Bread for a Philly Cheesesteak
Now that we know how crucial bread is to a Philly cheesesteak, let’s explore the best bread options to achieve the perfect sandwich.
Amoroso Rolls – The Gold Standard
If you ask any Philadelphia native what bread to use for a cheesesteak, the answer will almost always be Amoroso rolls. These rolls have been the gold standard for Philly cheesesteaks since the early 1900s.
Why Amoroso Rolls Are the Best Choice:
Soft yet sturdy – They hold up well without being too tough.
Slightly chewy texture – Gives the perfect bite.
Lightly crisp crust – Prevents sogginess without being too hard.
Authenticity – Used in almost every cheesesteak shop in Philadelphia.
Since Amoroso rolls are difficult to find outside of Philadelphia, many cheesesteak lovers look for alternatives that mimic their texture and taste.
Other Great Bread Options
If you can’t get Amoroso rolls, don’t worry! There are other excellent choices that work well for a Philly cheesesteak:
1. Hoagie Rolls
- A close second to Amoroso rolls, hoagie rolls have a similar soft yet firm texture.
- They are widely available in bakeries and grocery stores.
- Look for hoagie rolls with a light crust and a slightly chewy interior.
2. Italian Rolls
- Italian rolls can be a good option if they are not too hard or crusty.
- Choose ones that have a balanced texture—soft inside, slightly crisp outside.
- Avoid artisan-style Italian bread, as it’s too dense and crusty for a cheesesteak.
3. French Bread (Only Certain Types!)
- Some soft French bread loaves can work if they resemble hoagie rolls.
- Avoid baguettes, as they are too crunchy and will overpower the filling.
Soft vs. Crusty Bread: Which is Better?
The debate between soft vs. crusty bread for cheesesteaks comes down to texture and experience:
| Bread Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Soft Rolls (e.g., Amoroso, Hoagie) | Holds up well, absorbs juices, and provides a balanced bite. | Can get soggy if overloaded with fillings. |
| Crusty Rolls (e.g., Artisan Italian, Baguette) | Adds extra crunch and firmness. | Too hard and competes with the steak and cheese, making it difficult to eat. |
Verdict: Soft yet sturdy bread is the best choice for a Philly cheesesteak. It complements the flavors and textures without overpowering the sandwich.
Now that we’ve covered the best bread options, let’s move on to how to choose the right bread based on your personal preference.
How to Choose the Right Bread for Your Cheesesteak
Selecting the perfect bread for your Philly cheesesteak goes beyond just picking any roll. The right bread enhances the flavor, texture, and overall experience. Here are some key factors to consider when choosing the best roll for your cheesesteak.
Texture & Density Considerations
The ideal roll should have a balanced texture—soft enough to bite through easily, yet dense enough to hold the filling without falling apart. Here’s what to look for:
Soft Interior – The bread should be light and airy inside, allowing it to soak up the juices without becoming mushy.
Slightly Chewy – A mild chewiness enhances the eating experience.
Thin, Light Crust – A soft crust is preferred over a thick, crunchy one.
Avoid:
Flimsy, super-soft sandwich bread – It will become soggy and fall apart.
Hard, crusty rolls (like baguettes) – Too tough and difficult to bite through.
Where to Buy the Best Rolls
Finding authentic Philly cheesesteak bread outside of Philadelphia can be challenging, but here are some great options:
1. Local Bakeries
Many Italian or artisan bakeries carry hoagie rolls or soft Italian rolls that are perfect for a cheesesteak. Look for rolls labeled:
- Hoagie Rolls
- Soft Italian Rolls
- Sub Rolls
2. Grocery Stores
Most grocery stores have freshly baked sandwich rolls that work well for cheesesteaks. Look in the bakery section for rolls that match the texture of Amoroso rolls.
3. Online Retailers
If you want true Amoroso rolls, you can order them online from specialty food websites that ship nationwide. Some great places to check include:
- Amorosobaking.com
- Goldbelly.com
- Phillyfood.com
By choosing the right bread, you’re already halfway to making an amazing Philly cheesesteak. Next, let’s discuss how to prepare the bread properly for the best results.
How to Prepare Bread for a Philly Cheesesteak
Once you’ve chosen the perfect roll, the next step is preparing it properly. The way you slice, toast, and handle the bread can make a huge difference in the texture and overall experience of your Philly cheesesteak.
Toasting vs. No Toasting: Which is Better?
A big debate in the cheesesteak world is whether to toast the bread or leave it soft.
Toasting Pros:
Adds a slight crispiness to prevent sogginess.
Helps hold up against juicy steak and melted cheese.
Enhances the bread’s texture and flavor.
Toasting Cons:
- If over-toasted, it can become too hard or crunchy.
- Not as soft as a traditional cheesesteak roll.
Best Practice: Lightly warm or toast the inside of the roll on a griddle for 30–60 seconds. This adds structure without making the bread too crispy.
The Right Way to Slice the Bread
Proper slicing ensures the filling stays in place and gives the best eating experience.
Slicing Tips:
Use a serrated knife – This helps avoid crushing the bread.
Slice lengthwise – Cut along the top or side but don’t slice all the way through—leave one edge connected like a hinge.
Open it gently – This creates a pocket for the steak and cheese to sit perfectly.
Pro Tip: Steam the Roll for Extra Softness
For a super authentic Philly cheesesteak experience, some people steam the bread before serving.
How to Steam Your Roll:
Place the roll in a paper towel and microwave for 5–10 seconds to soften it.
Alternatively, wrap the roll in foil and place it in a warm oven for a few minutes.
Steaming the bread replicates the fresh-baked texture of Amoroso rolls, making your cheesesteak even more authentic.
Now that we’ve covered how to prep the bread, let’s look at some common mistakes to avoid when selecting and preparing cheesesteak bread.
Common Mistakes When Choosing Bread
Even with the best ingredients, the wrong bread can ruin your Philly cheesesteak experience. Here are some of the most common mistakes people make when selecting and preparing cheesesteak rolls—and how to avoid them.
1. Using the Wrong Type of Bread
Avoid:
- Regular sandwich bread – Too soft and flimsy, falls apart under juicy steak and cheese.
- Baguettes or artisan bread – Too crusty and dense, making it hard to bite into.
- Hot dog buns or sub rolls with too much air – They lack the sturdiness needed for a cheesesteak.
Use Instead: Amoroso rolls, hoagie rolls, or soft Italian rolls with a slightly chewy texture.
2. Buying Low-Quality Rolls
Cheap, mass-produced rolls might seem convenient, but they often:
Lack flavor and texture.
Fall apart too quickly.
Absorb too much moisture and get soggy.
Solution: Buy fresh bakery rolls or order Amoroso rolls online for the best results.
3. Over-Toasting the Bread
Toasting the bread too much makes it:
- Too crunchy, overpowering the steak and cheese.
- Hard to chew, ruining the signature soft-yet-sturdy texture of a Philly cheesesteak.
Best Practice: Lightly toast the inside of the roll for 30–60 seconds, just enough to prevent sogginess without making it crunchy.
4. Slicing the Roll Incorrectly
A bad slice can lead to:
The roll splitting in half, causing the fillings to spill out.
An uneven cut, making it harder to hold the sandwich together.
How to Slice It Right:
- Cut the roll lengthwise but don’t slice all the way through—leave one side attached like a hinge.
- This helps hold the steak, cheese, and toppings in place for the perfect bite.
5. Not Warming or Steaming the Roll
A cold, stiff roll can ruin the texture of your cheesesteak.
Fix:
- Lightly warm the bread in an oven, skillet, or microwave before serving.
- Steam it slightly for a soft, fresh-baked texture.
By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll get the best possible cheesesteak bread experience. Next, let’s answer some of the most frequently asked questions about choosing and preparing cheesesteak rolls.
FAQs: Bread for a Philly Cheesesteak
Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about choosing and preparing the best bread for a Philly cheesesteak.
1. Can I use regular sandwich bread for a Philly cheesesteak?
No, sandwich bread is too soft and flimsy. It won’t hold up against the juicy steak and melted cheese, leading to a messy and disappointing experience. Stick to hoagie rolls, Italian rolls, or Amoroso rolls for the best results.
2. What’s the difference between hoagie rolls and cheesesteak rolls?
While both hoagie rolls and cheesesteak rolls come from Philadelphia’s sandwich culture, hoagie rolls are sometimes slightly firmer. Cheesesteak rolls (like Amoroso’s) are softer and have a perfect balance of chewiness and structure.
3. Should I butter my cheesesteak roll?
Butter isn’t traditionally used in Philly cheesesteaks. However, some people lightly butter and toast the inside of the roll for extra flavor. This is more of a personal preference than a traditional method.
4. Can I make my own cheesesteak bread at home?
Yes! If you want to bake your own rolls, look for recipes for soft Italian sandwich rolls or hoagie rolls. The key is to achieve a soft interior with a slightly crisp, thin crust.
Conclusion
The bread you choose for your Philly cheesesteak can make or break the sandwich. The best rolls are soft yet sturdy, with a slight chew and light crispiness. Amoroso rolls are the gold standard, but hoagie rolls or soft Italian rolls are excellent alternatives.
When preparing your cheesesteak, remember these key tips:
Choose a soft, chewy roll that holds up to steak and cheese.
Avoid overly soft or crusty bread that will either fall apart or be too hard to eat.
Lightly toast or warm the roll for the best texture.
Slice the roll correctly to create a pocket for the filling.
Steam the roll slightly for an ultra-authentic Philly experience.
By following these guidelines, you’ll create a perfect Philly cheesesteak every time. Now, all that’s left to do is fire up the griddle, get your steak and cheese ready, and enjoy an authentic cheesesteak experience!
Looking for more delicious ideas? Try this Salmon Soup for a comforting meal. If you’re into sweet treats, learn How to Freeze Christmas Truffles to keep them fresh longer. Explore more recipes at Famed Recipes!